Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Dissidents need the ability to conduct private conversations to reduce the ability of the government to silence them.

Take the example of the Black Panther Party marching into the California State Capitol with shotguns. Under the laws of the day, it was perfectly legal. There was no intent to break any law. Yet, had the authorities been able to determine that they were planning this, they would have been stopped.

Private communication is essential to the planning of public discourse.



The government silencing protest is the problem there, not a lack of privacy. Dissidents don't have that need if society and government allow free expression.


If the government were perfect, then privacy might not be that much of an issue. Until then, privacy is often a useful stopgap measure.


Some governments today would view a protest like this as a possible terrorist action.

For what it's worth this example more than any other, that I've heard, explains why privacy is important.


Government silencing protest is a problem, it is not THE problem.

We should do whatever necessary to make it as difficult as possible for governments to silence protests.

There is less need for dissidents if the society and government allow the free airing of grievances.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: