Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

That... makes absolutely no sense.

We're in a golden age for music creation, you don't even need a garage and a band to get started (though it certainly helps for the more complex acts or if you want a band), people like Bo Burnham and Jacob Collier got their start (and part of their early fame) making youtube videos at home.

And probably most importantly you have no need whatsoever to be "discovered" by an "agent" or somesuch, you can have viewers and listeners from the other side of the globe, from your room.

I mean just look at this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IcVEx6UrtF8

That's a teenager in england (skillfully) playing with dissonant harmony in split-screen multitrack. The top commenter is a californian who'd go on to found Patreon the following month (or had founded it a month after the video was posted, youtube doesn't show exact dates for comments).



If it makes no sense, why do I not hear any modern great singers on the radio? On TV? In the movies? Getting awards?


Beyonce? Taylor Swift? Lady Gaga (see A Star is Born)? Bruno Mars? Rihanna? Katy Perry? Billie Eilish? Camila Cabello? Hell, even Justin Bieber.


Please post a youtube link you feel is representative of your point. I've been generous providing links supporting my findings. Your turn!

But hey, let's look at the first on your list, Beyonce:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2pPe7sxMVAY

Autotuned all the way. It sounds sweetened, as her tone changes from song to song. It sounds "adjusted" in a way I never hear from older songs. This is apparent around the 48 minute mark. Sometimes she pushes too hard and it sounds a bit screechy.

I saw (and heard!) A Star Is Born. I was so impressed by her singing, I rushed out and didn't buy the soundtrack, and can't recall anything she sung. Oh well. Julie Andrews she ain't.

Julie Andrews is probably the greatest female singer that ever existed. (Well, Marni Nixon who was so good she secretly dubbed the other stars deserves accolades!)


It's trivial to do so yourself if you just looked for live or acoustic performances. And there are even videos that do the work of isolating vocals for you:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LUrjHF_vaY4

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=siPZOWMhXdA

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ien38Lw2OLw

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cWnFnupgzdA


For your listening pleasure, may I present:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AVER6hyoyJo

And just for fun, from 1987, best cover evar:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2AUOAGlASRQ

> if you just looked for

It's sad to have to dig for them.


Yes, yes, I’ve already seen the trailer for the new Matrix sequel which rather hamfistedly uses that song.

Most of those videos are easily found simply by searching “$ARTIST [no autotune | acoustic | live]”.


I didn't know that about the Matrix sequel. Being a crusty old moron, as other HNers have accurately labeled me, I thought the first Matrix sucked and so never watched the sequels.

But don't you think it's sad that a modern movie has to reach back in time 35 years to find a good song to use?

(I bought that Sanctuary album back in the 80's, when Brain Pain was broadcasting their metal show weekly. I miss Brain Pain.)


Hell, Collier has already collected 5 grammies, and managed to get at least one for each of his first four albums.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: