Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Having been in Big Law myself, I have previously set forth my thoughts at some length on this topic (see http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1648342).

Fundamentally, law remains a guild system, with the governing licensing restrictions severely limiting the ability to innovate. Only licensed persons can be owners of firms and only licensed persons can provide the key services. No fee-splitting or profit sharing is permitted with any person who is not licensed. Even one who is licensed is limited is performing services other than in the locale for which he is licensed. All of this may be well and good for "maintaining standards," as the bar associations say, but it means this is and will remain a closed profession that remains remote and removed from average people.

This is not a knock on professionalism. A really good lawyer is well worth the price, even at high rates, for many business transactions. But making services broadly affordable remains a challenge. Technology can help as long as the laws bend enough to allow firms to adopt innovative business models taking advantage of it - how far this can go will ultimately depend on the rules of the guild.



This is a great comment, but one nitpick: "No fee-splitting or profit sharing is permitted with any person who is not licensed."

I believe this is no longer the case the UK and some other places.


Fair enough, and perhaps your comment is a sign of change. However, though this is a global forum, the source article is from the American Bar Association.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: