Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

You're beating a dead horse. Flash served a purpose once, and now it's reached end-of-life.


> You're beating a dead horse

With a foam bat. Just because the flash horse is dead doesn't mean it didn't deserve it's beating or can't continue to be a potent reminder of how bad Adobe was at handling security issues and why other platforms, like Steam, should learn instead of emulate.


This also has nothing to do with Flash specifically, rather as you said Adobe's policy. It could have been any software but especially for Flash.

Flash was just such a unique special target, ala PDFs and Microsoft word, there were few wide open targets from which a hacker could predictably get the user to open (whether embedded or not) on a targets machine. So it was particularly sensitive to vulnerabilities by design, where a much broader security perspective was clearly needed than most software.


I'd prefer to describe it as slashing a dead horse's rotten corpse with a katana. As the bloat and flesh of the ecosystem has disintegrated we're able to observe the framework more clearly - the bone structure of the horse, if you will. Using the katana we are making precise, incisive blows to the remnants as we extract meaning from it's corpse - or lessons learned, if you will.

...perhaps I'm taking the analogy too far?


No, they're making a point about Valve by comparing them to Adobe.


Flash died because Adobe failed in the most obvious ways--even to lay outsiders at the time. They could never be bothered to fix the pervasive performance or security issues. It started to die, slowly at first: the desktop flash blocker plugins. Then very quickly: the lack of support from mobile OS--even though those companies practically begged Adobe to get its act together.

Adobe had a practical monopoly on the interactive web and blew it.


Now I’m just waiting for Steam to follow their lead.


.... Hit the dead horse with the foam bat and win an iPod?

Those were the old days. Or, that damned monkey!


It reached its EOL because Steve Jobs considered it a buggy security threat.

If no one will use or manufacture your baseball bat, then the danger of the bat is moot.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: