Better returns directly on the money (given historical averages hold) yes. You also have to consider I'm locking in my monthly housing cost in 2016 prices (until I pay off the mortgage that is, then I merely have to pay property taxes) also I can make improvements to my standard of living that renters can't. If I want a hot tub, I simply install one rather than having to find an apartment with one and paying a massive monthly premium for it. Rent for a decent one bedroom in my area is $1200 a month, my mortgage is $1120 (taxes and insurance included) and that gives me 3 bedrooms and a yard. For me this was the better choice.