Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Loss of privilege is often perceived as oppression.

On the other hand, the creator of Dilbert just shrugged it off and started a new job each time his employer said they couldn't promote another white male.



equality requires not a loss of privilege, but an equal distribution of privilege. This means hiring/firing should give an equal consideration to both genders.

A 50/50 m/f ratio is not a statistical "proof of equality".


Yeah, Rosa Parks shoulda shrugged it off and waited for another bus!

Seriously though, 'often' is just a weasel word if you don't specify the context. This might qualify as a mechanism for dismissing valid complaints...


Are you comparing discrimination against black people in the 50s to what may have happened to a man? A lot of civil rights activists wanted affirmative action too.

Often is most of the time. People perceive relative changes as terrible. That's why they arrested Parks instead of agreeing with her.


Why? It's an analogy, the relevant parts match; There's no rule that says discrimination has to reach a certain level before it should be resisted . Stop derailing my point with irrelevancies.

"A lot of civil rights activist" - which ones and why? Maybe their reasoning is sensitive to their particular interest.

I understand what 'often' means, I don't agree with it as a generality. Even 'People perceive relative changes as terrible' isn't always true.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: